Controller code.. your opinion?

[eluser]Adam Griffiths[/eluser]
I always use the first version, it's probably because when I used procedural code I had different files for each action, and it just stuck. I can see the benefits of having all the edit functions in one controller, for example.

Although it would get messy if you had a modular structure like I use now, which is why I stick with the first. But then again I would have the whole function in a model and just run it from the controller.