New vid: 3 New Features in CI 4.0.4 |
Where to point out not best choices for the user guide and or user guide examples?
(sorry to be slightly off topic and though sorry but I can't help with development, but I can do something with user guide hints and enhancements) e.g. https://codeigniter.com/user_guide/incom...aceholders the first snippet is PHP Code: $routes->add('product/(:num)', 'App\Catalog::productLookup'); In a route, the first parameter contains the URI to be matched, while the second parameter contains the destination it should be re-routed to. In the above example, if the literal word “product” is found in the first segment of the URL, and a number is found in the second segment, the “AppCatalog” class and the “productLookup” method are used instead. it should be :any instead as written later in the examples PHP Code: $routes->add('product/(:any)', 'Catalog::productLookup'); or again, taken from the examples, it should be changed to a less confusing PHP Code: 'Catalog::productLookupByID/$1' if you agree, like the later example shows PHP Code: $routes->add('product/(:num)', 'Catalog::productLookupByID/$1'); the first snippet will kill newbies and students especially when they later will reach the examples section I have seen others (sort of) incongruities around, like the word 'post' choosen to be written lowercase in the blog tutorial were post will be confused by post/posts in the blog, where the tutorial itself referers to a blog, instead it could clarify writing POST uppercase I mean this page https://codeigniter.com/user_guide/tutor...items.html if you go to the the second section "Create a form", its code snippet is PHP Code: <h2><?= esc($title); ?></h2> method="post", just to "help" newbies and students, can be written method="POST" yes PHP coders will laugh .. but the tutorial is such basic that I would guess is NOT meant to be thought nor for PHP experienced coders neither for just PHP coders , it is meant for newbies and students, since unhappily the tutorial context is the one of a blog, the 'post' lowercase will cause a short-circuit in the newbie reader ----- Just to mention a couple So could turn in a a courteous kindness towards students readers, to edit the tutorial and begin fixing these two P.S. kindly allow to add a third one the controversy routes in this page https://codeigniter.com/user_guide/incom...ting-rules a brief introduction is written but immediately right after it begins a section PlaceHolders https://codeigniter.com/user_guide/incom...aceholders where the the Code: add() ... well the implication suggests that e.g. $routes->add('product/(:num)', 'App\Catalog::productLookup'); should be written into the app/config/Routes.php file ... but nowhere along the page is found a snippet with a practical example , nowhere in the entire https://codeigniter.com/user_guide/incom...uting.html page and to be honest, I just guess it and I ask myself too, are all those $routes->add() to be written in app/config/Routes.php? and if the code $routes->add('product/(:num)', 'App\Catalog::productLookup'); has to be placed in that file ... where it should be added? in /** * -------------------------------------------------------------------- * Router Setup * -------------------------------------------------------------------- */ or in /** * -------------------------------------------------------------------- * Route Definitions * -------------------------------------------------------------------- */ or /** * -------------------------------------------------------------------- * Additional Routing * -------------------------------------------------------------------- */ everything above could look silly but these are the questions that will make students to abandon
I was developing my project with CI3, however after checking CI4, I felt in love!
Thank you.
(01-16-2021, 03:01 AM)Corsari Wrote: Where to point out not best choices for the user guide and or user guide examples?Sending Pull Requests is the best way. https://github.com/codeigniter4/CodeIgni...IBUTING.md https://github.com/codeigniter4/CodeIgni...README.rst |
Welcome Guest, Not a member yet? Register Sign In |