PHP mail works, CI email lib does not

[eluser]Chris abcdefg[/eluser]
I configured an SMTP server accessible via localhost.

PHP mail() command works fine, I use it in scheduled tasks to email backups as attachments.

If I use CodeIgniter v1.7.2 email library using the following code, and the CI debug output says the message is sent, but the SMTP server logs show Bad Sender.

$this->CI->load->library('email');

$config['protocol'] = 'mail';
$config['smtp_host'] = 'localhost';
$config['mailtype'] = 'html';
$config['crlf'] = "\r\n"; // CHANGED FROM DEFAULTS
$config['newline'] = "\r\n"; // CHANGED FROM DEFAULTS

$this->CI->email->initialize($config);

$this->CI->email->from('[email protected]');
$this->CI->email->to($_POST['email']);

$this->CI->email->subject('Password Reset');
$this->CI->email->message('Testing the email class. <a href="http://www.google.co.uk">test</a>');

$this->CI->email->send();
This is the log from PHP mail for 2 messages (changed domains to hiddendomain1/2)

03/10/11 16:26:39 ME-I0107: [496] Relay Granted: Sender IP (127.0.0.1) is within an authorized IP range.
03/10/11 16:26:39 ME-I0149: [496] AFAB1A79683B434EAD6A415C5DAA7D52.MAI was received successfully and delivery thread was initiated
03/10/11 16:26:39 ME-I0074: [496] (Debug) End of conversation
03/10/11 16:26:39 ME-I0107: [552] Relay Granted: Sender IP (127.0.0.1) is within an authorized IP range.
03/10/11 16:26:39 ME-I0149: [552] 16B8D83CD6B040489608FCE5E9C3A177.MAI was received successfully and delivery thread was initiated
03/10/11 16:26:39 ME-I0074: [552] (Debug) End of conversation
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0018: [8F72D521DC554A13AA1E0973090A75B9.MAI] Outbound message from ([SMTP:[email protected]]) requeued as [CC32D29A0BA34D9496B1602A8150B7EE.MAI] to the target domain [hiddendomain2.com]
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0123: Domain [hiddendomain2.com] has MX list [mailserver.hiddendomain2.com]
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0026: [CC32D29A0BA34D9496B1602A8150B7EE.MAI] Sending message
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0018: [9D2654AE500442E4A90DDFD75B98C0B5.MAI] Outbound message from ([SMTP:[email protected]]) requeued as [90EF8F85B103431FB14A32F535AFFFFD.MAI] to the target domain [hiddendomain2.com]
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0123: Domain [hiddendomain2.com] has MX list [mailserver.hiddendomain2.com]
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0026: [90EF8F85B103431FB14A32F535AFFFFD.MAI] Sending message
03/10/11 16:26:40 ME-I0049: [CC32D29A0BA34D9496B1602A8150B7EE.MAI] Send Completed Successfully
03/10/11 16:26:41 ME-I0049: [90EF8F85B103431FB14A32F535AFFFFD.MAI] Send Completed Successfully
This is the log after sending via CodeIgniter, as you can see the CI email library is adding the < char to the From address, can any help tell me why? is this is bug with CI?

03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-I0107: [568] Relay Granted: Sender IP (127.0.0.1) is within an authorized IP range.
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-I0149: [568] B1D7A0FCDF44403291E8EAD33F5F144F.MAI was received successfully and delivery thread was initiated
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-I0074: [568] (Debug) End of conversation
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-I0018: [38DFE013802046528FAC7823871869CC.MAI] Outbound message from ([SMTP:<[email protected]]) requeued as [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] to the target domain [hiddendomain2.com]
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-I0123: Domain [hiddendomain2.com] has MX list [mailserver.hiddendomain2.com]
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-I0026: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] Sending message
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-IXXXX: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] Remote server returned a response indicating a permanent error. Server Response: (501 Bad sender address syntax**)
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-E0036: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] MAIL FROM command Failed.
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-E0008: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] Outbound, could not send the command to the server (error 10038).
03/10/11 16:26:42 ME-E0060: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] - Message could not be delivered to target domain (hiddendomain2.com). Message returned to Sender.
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0119: Domain [hiddendomain1.com] has used local loopback address [127.0.0.1] because it is hosted locally.
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0026: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] Sending message
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0102: [572] Address ([SMTP:<[email protected]]) is to be delivered to Catch-All address.
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0149: [572] CAEFBF802B8646DB99B4D2401571AE3E.MAI was received successfully and delivery thread was initiated
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0049: [AC83949E463246DDBD022BBF355D4606.MAI] Send Completed Successfully
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0074: [572] (Debug) End of conversation
03/10/11 16:26:43 ME-I0132: Catch-All Message rendered for CAEFBF802B8646DB99B4D2401571AE3E.MAI
It looks the bug was reported here but shunned off as a problem with the SMTP server but it seems the problem is indeed a compatibility issues with the CI lib: http://ellislab.com/forums/viewthread/114030/

I am pretty damn sure that this is a problem with CI as PHP mail works fine. Can anyone confirm? because if not I need to change the script I use with CI. I can provide any logs / details

[eluser]Chris abcdefg[/eluser]
Yea.. I hate CI..

Code:

//DOESNT FREAKIN WORK - SMTP LOG SHOWS BAD FROM ADDRESS
/*
            $this->CI->load->library('email');

            //$config['protocol'] = 'mail';
            $config['smtp_host'] = 'localhost';
            $config['mailtype'] = 'html';
            $config['crlf']        = "\r\n";        // CHANGED FROM DEFAULTS
            $config['newline']     = "\r\n";        // CHANGED FROM DEFAULTS

            $this->CI->email->initialize($config);

            $this->CI->email->from('[email protected]');
            $this->CI->email->to($_POST['email']);

            $this->CI->email->subject('Password Reset');
            $this->CI->email->message('Testing the email class. <a href="http://www.google.co.uk">test</a>');    

            $this->CI->email->send();
*/
//WORKS USING LOCALHOST
$to = $_POST['email'];
$subject = 'Password Reset';
$headers = "From: [email protected]\r\n";
$headers .= "MIME-Version: 1.0\r\n";
$headers .= "Content-Type: text/html; charset=ISO-8859-1\r\n";
$message = '&lt;html&gt;&lt;body>';
$message .= 'Your account has been flagged for a password reset.<br><br>To set a new password, please use the following link:<br>____';
$message .= "&lt;/body&gt;&lt;/html>";
mail($to, $subject, $message, $headers);