Default Controller Issue

[eluser]mddd[/eluser]
Could your 'defaultindex' be causing trouble? I mean, if the server comes across something that is not an existing file (maybe something like /page/index/abc) can't it be that the server will then redirect you to index.php, as that is the default index?
Try removing that line and see what happens.

Also, to help us understand, is Page your default controller or are you trying to call the Page controller but getting another controller which is your default?