What's your favorite CI Auth plugin

[eluser]Ben Bowler[/eluser]
I'm looking for a stable, scalable auth plugin to use for a large membership based site. So far I've come across these:

http://codeigniter.com/wiki/auth/
http://icebergist.com/posts/simple-passw...odeigniter
https://github.com/benedmunds/CodeIgniter-Ion-Auth

What's your preference?

[eluser]tkaw220[/eluser]
I had tried out the Ion Auth but end up I write my own solution from scratch for better control and simplicity.

[eluser]JamieBarton[/eluser]
Yeah there's a lot of Auth systems which are bloated, but I wrote my own which I use in all my personal projects now.

Ion Auth is good, if you get your head around all the stuff.

[eluser]Ben Bowler[/eluser]
OK thanks. It's seems like building my own is the best bet.

[eluser]Maglok[/eluser]
I like ion auth. Writing my own isn't as comprehensive as using ion auth (salts, basic functions, meta tables, groups) I just don't have the time to think out and write one to spec.

If I do a lot of projects I grab ion Auth by default and only deviate if the requirements are different then what it can provide.

[eluser]Stoney[/eluser]
My choice is dx_auth.

The best thing with dx_auth is that only one line is needed in your controller to protect it.
$this->dx_auth->check_uri_permissions();

[eluser]ecsyle31[/eluser]
My favorite Auth Library is the one I wrote for myself.

[eluser]guidorossi[/eluser]
If you're looking for writing your own Library Greg made a great tutorial

http://www.gregaker.net/2010/dec/06/crea..._part_one/
http://www.gregaker.net/2010/dec/07/crea..._part_two/
http://www.gregaker.net/2010/dec/09/code...on_part_3/

I think he forgot part four, but it's really good... ;-)

[eluser]Vheissu[/eluser]
Ion Auth is pretty good, I've used it for a few projects of mine. I'm in the process of developing a driver based authentication library for Codeigniter that uses Codeigniter drivers. The plan is to have a couple of drivers (session driver and a Facebook driver). I'm planning on writing lots more including; Twitter, LinkedIn and Google - more will follow suit.

The link to the current uncompleted version is in my signature. WolfAuth.